How to Navigate Insurance Claims & Retain Your Right to Choose Your Repair Shop

Learn how to navigate insurance claims and choose the best repair shop .

For any car owner, the accident itself should be the hardest part to deal with - not the headaches trying to navigate the insurance claims process. Getting into an accident is already stressful enough. 

However, when the insurance company is pressuring you to use one of their 'preferred' and-generic-auto-parts shops - a practice that may put your safety at risk again - that's unacceptable. This guide provides clear, practical information to help you navigate your insurance claims and ensure your vehicle ends up in the right hands.

The Insurance Claim Complexity - Why It Feels Overwhelming 

Often, delays and paperwork, especially when you can't read through the fine print, create anxiety.

Moreover, pressure to use "approved" or "preferred" shops can be daunting. 

Some common fears include: “will my claim be denied?” “Will the repair be covered if I don't follow their suggestion?”

auto body shop  Insurance Claims

Understanding Your Rights as a Car Owner 

The Right to Choose Your Repair Shop 

As a car owner, let no insurance company pressure you into choosing from their recommended repair shop network. According to the law, you have the right to choose your own repair shop.

Insurance companies can only recommend, but not force you.  

The Truth About "Preferred" Repair Shops

More often than not, insurance companies push them to cut costs at the expense of standard repair services. 

According to the law, you have the right to choose your own repair shop. According to Troy A., the rise in repair part prices led to insurance companies squeezing body shops, resulting in substandard repairs

Potential Downsides

The potential downsides to insurance companies' preferred shops include cheaper parts, a lack of specialized expertise, and possible safety risks down the road. 

When it might be okay to use them - and when to say no. 

When to say “Okay”

1. You value convenience and efficiency 

Preferred shops often offer streamlined repair services due to the established ties. This makes the overall repair process fast.

2. Warranty: Many Direct Repair Programs (DRP)  offer a warranty on their repairs, which can provide peace of mind.

3. Minor, nonstructural repairs: for minor and nonstructural repairs that do not require part replacement and/or have high safety concerns, you can opt for preferred shops. 

When to say “NO”

1. Potential for low-quality or hurried repairs

If your car needs major repairs and maximum attention to get back on the road, you're better off saying no to preferred shops, as you know how fast they can be. 

2. Loss of Autonomy and Control 

When you entrust your vehicle to an insurer's preferred repair shop, you may have less or no control over the repair process. Why? Because the insurer dictates your vehicle’s fate. 

3. Safety Concerns 

If repair involves structural damage or significant components, you should consider rejecting the insurer's preferred repair shop because it may result in the use of non-OEM parts that compromise your car's safety and integrity.

How to Navigate the Insurance Claim Process Without Losing Control 

Step 1. Report the accident as soon as possible 

Step 2. Document everything (photographs, notes, police report)

Step 3. Review Your Insurance Policy. Focus on the fine print.  

Step 4. Politely but confidently state your repair shop preference. 

Step 5. Keep documenting the process whenever necessary. 

Note: Your choice of repair shop matters.  Quality repair equals safety and preserves the worth of your car.  

Regal Repair Advantage 

  • If you are looking for a reputable auto repair shop, Regal Repair is your top choice. 
  • Choosing Regal Repair as your partner in restoring your car is a smart decision.  Why? 
  • Regal Repair has experience in handling insurance claims on behalf of our customers. 
  • Direct communication with the insurer can help reduce our customers' stress. 
  • We have experienced and qualified technicians who ensure excellent vehicle restoration. 

In conclusion 

You have the right to say both yes and no to insurance company pressure to accept their "preferred" shops. 

Furthermore, car owners can make informed decisions about what to agree to and what not to agree to based on the nature of the vehicle damage. 

P.S. If you're filing a claim, let Regal Repair guide you through it. 

Recent from the Blog

Read our posts, news, tips and articles

Collision Repair Coupons

Save even more at Regal Repair for all your collision repair needs. Take advantage of our special collision repair coupons and deals to get your vehicle back in shape without overspending. Whether it's a minor dent or major damage, our offers provide affordable, high-quality repair solutions. Don't miss out on these limited-time discounts – explore our deals today and ensure your car receives the best care at the best price! Please mention the website coupon at the time of the vehicle estimate.

Repair Your Vehicle at Regal and Get

$500
Coupon With Any Collision Repair
Min. $2800 repair job. Coupon may be used toward any Regal Repair services.

Before returning your leased car to the Dealer, get

FREE
Lease Return Repair Inspection
Can be combined

Make it easy with a

FREE
Car Loaner or Rental
Up to $80 of rental car cost, with min. repair cost of $2800
* Not valid with other services or promotions. For a limited time only. Additional exclusions may apply. Offer must be mentioned/presented at time of estimate. Void where prohibited.

Expires on 12/31/

Multiple Collision Repair centers, conveniently located Near You.

Your trusted auto body shop and collision center, proudly serving you from our locations in North Hollywood and Los Angeles, CA. Let us take care of your collision repair needs, insurance negotiations, car rentals, and put your mind at ease. Get a free estimate today! Call us, schedule an appointment online or stop by during business hours.
N. Hollywood, CA
Regal Repair - North Hollywood is conveniently located on Cahuenga Blvd. in NoHo near Toluca Lake. The nearest cross street is Chandler St.

Regal Repair - NoHo

Address: 5430 Cahuenga Blvd., N. Hollywood, CA 91601
Hours of Operation
Mon-Fri:8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sat: 9:00 AM - 2:00 PM (by appointment)
Sunday: Closed
Services offered: Complete Collision Repair Facility, Auto Body Repair and Paint, Mechanical Services, Wheel Alignment and Tires.
24/7 Emergency Service Available
Los Angeles, CA
Regal Repair -  LA is conveniently located on5252 W. 111th St., Los Angeles CA, 90045.

Regal Repair - LA

Address: 5252 W. 111th St., Los Angeles CA, 90045
Hours of Operation
Mon-Fri:8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sat: 9:00 AM - 2:00 PM (by appointment)
Sunday: Closed
Services offered: Collision Repair Center
24/7 Emergency Service Available